This spring, I moved into my first home, and though I love it, it’s a townhouse that lacks a proper backyard (which hurts my gardening heart). So, I got inventive and added a raised garden bed, and after testing, I may never go back to the worms and backaches of in-ground gardening again.
My fellow editors and I put five more raised garden beds to the test so you can choose the right one for summer gardening—some have been beloved for over five years now, a testament to their longevity.
Before buying a garden bed, consider how much space you have, what you’d like to grow, and how much assembly sounds reasonable to you. Our recommendations will suit any situation, whether a patio herb garden or a large bed for tomatoes and zucchini.
Convenient self-watering feature
Sturdy and durable (even in extreme weather)
Great value for the price
There was no clearer option for our best overall recommendation than the Keter Splendor Raised Garden Bed—our writer, Jeremy, has owned this now for five years without a single complaint. It’s survived a direct hit from a hurricane and still looks great and is perfect for many vegetables, from okra to heirloom tomatoes to banana peppers.
The setup is easy and can be completed solo. The legs pop right in without needing tools, there’s a false bottom that supports the soil with a space at the bottom for the water reservoir, and a tube that runs through to show when the reservoir is full.
Meet the Tester
Jeremy has been gardening since 2007, learning from his grandpa and great-grandma. He gardens in Florida using raised containers, since his only soil option is essentially sand from the canal.
I love that this option includes a self-watering feature, since a common problem with raised beds is the soil drying out quickly. There is a little pop-up indicator (cutely shaped like a leaf) that shows how full the reservoir is and takes the guesswork out of watering.
Another smart feature: the drain plug at the bottom, which you can pull if you’re experiencing a lot of rainfall to avoid swamping plants. I think this bed is versatile for vegetables, flowers, and herbs, too, so it works for a variety of gardeners.
Dimensions: 45 x 19 x 30 inches︱Material: Polypropylene resin︱Assembly Required: Yes
Simple and easy-to-complete assembly
Durable and weather-resistant
Beautiful rustic, farmhouse look
What I don’t love about raised garden beds is how costly it becomes to buy and fill raised garden beds, so saving a bit on the actual container is highly advantageous. That’s a great aspect of the Keter 29-Gallon Elevated Garden Bed, which provides tons of growing space at a nice price.
During testing, we planted basil, tomatoes, and marigolds in this bed, but we think it’s great for growing anything. Though we wish the weather were better, we were impressed with how well this held up in the rain, cold, and wind. The faux wood helps ease your mind from fading or other damage.
Meet the Tester
Jenica has gardened for decades and used raised garden beds for the last five years (she swears by them!) In this bed, she grows basil, tomatoes, and some flowers.
The simple setup is a huge pro—this took less than an hour with clear directions and not-too-many small pieces. It’s also worth mentioning the gorgeous farmhouse design, which is sure to enhance the look of your patio.
Similar to our best overall, this has the same pop-up water level indicator and drain plug to avoid overwatering plants. It’s unclear after putting it together if it’s truly self-watering, but we haven’t noticed any watering issues so far.
We can’t think of much to change about this bed, other than the portability—once full, it would be really difficult to move, so we wish it came on wheels. But if you want a permanent piece to last for garden seasons to come, this is a great option.
Dimensions: 44 x 19 x 31 inches︱Material: Plastic︱Assembly Required: Yes
Gorgeous design with lots of space to grow
Solid, sturdy construction
Lots of size options
As mentioned, raised garden beds are notorious for needing constant watering, since the moisture from the ground doesn’t help hydrate plant roots. But, in comes the self-watering garden bed from Vego Garden to save the day! Its large wicking cells store and distribute water to your plant babies as needed and provide lots of growing room for crops of all kinds.
This is the option I have at my townhouse—while I thought moving was going to limit my growing options, I fit six tomato plants, six pepper plants, and over eight cucumbers towards the back, which will grow up a trellis. I think this bed would look beautiful with flowers, too.
Meet the Tester
I’m Mia, an experienced gardener going on my tenth growing season in New Jersey. I usually plant in the ground or in larger landscape garden beds, growing lots of veggies like tomatoes, zucchini, and cucumbers.
This holds whatever you like—fruits, veggies, flowers, or herbs, too. It stores water at the bottom and distributes it evenly to your plants, so you can be assured they’re staying hydrated from the bottom. I also love the iconic design and color options—it’ll complement your yard without being an eyesore.
As a note, the website says assembly takes “just a few minutes,” but this took me about an hour to build (with some teamwork). There are several small bolts and nuts to keep track of, but once built, it has a sturdy frame that hasn’t moved an inch.
Dimensions: 2 x 4, 2 x 6, or 2 x 8 feet︱Material: VZ 2.0 (Steel & zinc alloy)︱Assembly Required: Yes
Built-in water reservoir
Beautiful, timeless design
Withstands rain and wind with ease
Not all garden beds have to look utilitarian, which is one of the many reasons we love the Devon Garden Planter from Grandin Road. Its beautiful design, simple assembly, and durable frame won us over during testing as we established our herb garden.
Strong rain and winds are no match for this raised garden bed, likely thanks to the unique design of the plastic growing container and wooden legs. Our previous raised garden bed was all wood, and it looked worn in comparison to this one.
Meet the Tester
Daniela is in the early stages of her gardening journey, and this is her third year growing crops in New Jersey. She grew herbs and a few peppers in a wooden raised garden bed for the past two years. As she recently moved to a new home, she replaced that bed with this one.
Assembling the raised garden bed was easy. We had to put together the legs, which form the frame of the bed. As a note, you do need a cordless drill to screw the nails in, which we figured out mid-assembly. Once the frame is done, place the plastic bin of the bed on it, and you’re done.
One cool feature of the raised garden bed is the water reservoir. It’s been raining a lot in New Jersey, so we love that the bed collects water underneath it to distribute later. We wish we had chosen the black color so it shows less dirt, though a little power washing or a garden hose can help.
Dimensions: 48 x 18 x 30 inches︱Material: Polyethylene resin︱Assembly Required: Yes
Herbs are beautiful when planted between veggies, but why not give them their own dedicated space? This bed has several compartments to let each herb thrive in its own home, and the compact size doesn’t take up too much room on our patio.
We’ve had this garden bed for four years now and can keep on growing in it. In our experience, it suits herbs best rather than larger crops like tomatoes, but we could see this as the perfect vessel for a flower garden, too.
Meet the Tester
Jenica is an experienced gardener in New York who uses wood and metal raised garden beds. In this bed, she planted her herb garden and cherry tomatoes (which didn’t hold up as well).
Another great aspect of this is its construction. There’s a handy shelf underneath to store pots, garden tools, and soil, plus the height is perfect. We didn’t have to bend over to use it, though this might change for taller gardeners.
I recommend covering this in the wintertime or storing it in the garage, as the wood faded and weathered in a few places during testing.
Dimensions: 23 inches tall︱Material: Cedar Wood︱Assembly Required: Yes
How We Tested Raised Garden Beds
We tested several different raised garden beds across the country, varying in height, material, and features.
Ease of setup: No one wants to spend all day putting together a garden bed—you want to get to the good part, the planting! We noted how long assembly and setup took for each of these beds, including how involved it was, and how many little pieces were scattered around the yard afterwards.
The Spruce
Durability: You want peace of mind that your raised garden bed can stand up to the elements. Luckily, there was a lot of weather for us to deal with over the testing period. We were able to see how well the beds performed in wind, rain, and heat.
The Spruce
Spaciousness: Some beds are better suited for certain crops than others. We noted how spacious each was and what would grow best inside.
The Spruce
Design: These are now huge highlights of our backyards, so we awarded extra points if the design was particularly pretty and eye-catching.
The Spruce
Overall Value: Raised garden beds can be pricey, making the whole task cost much more than you’d like. We scored the overall value based on the quality and number of special features each bed has.
The Spruce
What to Look for in a Raised Garden Bed
A Comfortable Height for Gardening
Standard raised ground beds sit directly on the ground and are typically 6 to 8 inches high, like our best self-watering pick, the Vego Garden Self-Watering Garden Bed. Because of their low height, users need to bend or crouch down when tending to plants.
Elevated raised garden beds, like our best overall pick, the Keter Splendor Garden Bed, offer a growing space at a more comfortable standing or sitting height. These beds have legs or are supported by a stand or trolley.
Durable Construction Materials
You can find raised garden beds in a variety of materials, including wood, plastic, metal, steel, and polyethylene.
- Wood: Choose a wood such as cedar or fir that is naturally weather-resistant or comes pre-sealed to create a more traditional, rustic aesthetic.
- Plastic and polyethylene beds are often more modern or utilitarian in design. While not very stylish, plastic options are often more lightweight and easier to clean.
- Metal: If you live in a harsh climate and durability is a top priority, a bed made of steel, like our best self-watering pick, the Vego Garden Self-Watering Garden Bed, is a solid option.
Extra Features
Raised garden beds are advantageous for many reasons: the ability to garden on spots like a deck or patio, fewer weeds to deal with, and easier to reach (some are so high up, you don’t even need to bend over).
Many raised garden beds have special features to enhance the gardening experience, like self-watering reservoirs, attachable trellises, and wheels to make them easier to move. Some of these special features are present in our favorites, like the self-watering capabilities of our best design and best overall options.
Why Trust The Spruce?
I’m Mia Ingui, an editor at The Spruce who is an experienced gardener, growing bushels of tomatoes and cucumbers year after year. Though this was my first time trying a raised garden bed, I fell in love with the Vego Garden Self-Watering Bed as a great solution to my townhouse’s lack of growing space.
To compile this list, I took insights from my fellow editors and parsed through the feedback on their raised garden beds, all taking note of the ease of setup, size, durability, and overall value.